Select Page

What gemstones offer the best value beside diamonds?

What Gemstones Offer the Best Value Besides Diamonds?

While diamonds continue to reign supreme in the jewelry world, there are numerous alternative gemstones that offer exceptional value, beauty, and uniqueness. At Creekside Jewelers, we believe in helping our customers find the perfect gemstone that matches both their aesthetic preferences and budget considerations. In this comprehensive guide, we’ll explore the best value gemstones that deserve your attention.

Sapphires: The Royal Alternative

Sapphires have long been treasured for their stunning blue hues and remarkable durability. With a hardness of 9 on the Mohs scale, they’re second only to diamonds in terms of durability, making them an excellent choice for engagement rings in Golden, CO. While blue is the most recognized color, sapphires naturally occur in almost every color of the rainbow—except red (which would be classified as a ruby).

What makes sapphires particularly valuable is their versatility and lasting appeal. The famous engagement ring once worn by Princess Diana and now by Kate Middleton features a stunning blue sapphire, cementing these gems as a royal alternative to the traditional diamond. For those seeking custom jewelry in Golden, CO, sapphires offer an excellent canvas for unique designs.

At Creekside Jewelers in Denver, we’ve noticed increasing interest in “Montana sapphires,” which are mined domestically and often feature unique teal and blue-green colors. These American gems typically cost 20-40% less than comparable Kashmir or Ceylon sapphires while offering distinctive beauty and ethical sourcing advantages.

Moissanite: Diamond’s Brilliant Competitor

Moissanite has rapidly gained popularity as one of the best diamond alternatives available today. Originally discovered in a meteor crater in 1893, today’s moissanite is lab-created and offers extraordinary brilliance—actually exceeding that of diamonds due to its higher refractive index. For those shopping for wedding rings in Golden, CO, moissanite presents an ethical and budget-friendly alternative.

With a hardness of 9.25 on the Mohs scale, moissanite is extremely durable for everyday wear. The most compelling aspect of moissanite, however, is its value proposition. A one-carat moissanite typically costs about 10% of what you’d pay for a comparable diamond. This remarkable value allows customers at Creekside Jewelers in Boulder to get substantially larger stones within the same budget.

Modern moissanite has come a long way in mimicking diamond’s appearance. While earlier versions had a slight greenish or yellowish tint in certain lighting, today’s “colorless” moissanite is virtually indistinguishable from a diamond to the untrained eye. The dispersion (fire) of moissanite is actually higher than that of diamonds, giving these stones exceptional sparkle that many customers at our jewelry store in Golden, CO specifically seek out.

Rubies: Passionate and Precious

Rubies have captivated humanity for centuries with their rich red color symbolizing passion, power, and love. Technically a red variety of corundum (the same mineral as sapphires), rubies offer exceptional durability with a hardness of 9, making them perfect for engagement rings in Denver, CO and other everyday jewelry pieces.

While fine quality rubies can command prices similar to diamonds, there is tremendous value to be found in rubies with slight inclusions or in specific color ranges. At Creekside Jewelers’ gemstone collection, we offer Burmese and Thai rubies that provide exceptional value compared to flawless specimens while still offering the distinctive ruby appearance.

For those seeking alternatives to the deepest red varieties, pink sapphires (technically very light rubies) offer similar appeal at a significantly lower price point. We’ve helped many customers at our Arvada jewelry store find beautiful pink sapphires that deliver the romance of ruby without the premium price tag. Heat-treated rubies also present excellent value, offering enhanced color stability at prices 30-50% lower than their untreated counterparts.

Emeralds: Timeless Green Elegance

Emeralds have been treasured for thousands of years, with their lush green color symbolizing rebirth and prosperity. As one of the traditional “precious gemstones,” emeralds offer historical significance and timeless appeal that many customers at Creekside Jewelers in Golden appreciate in their fine jewelry.

Unlike diamonds, emeralds are valued differently—inclusions (called “jardin” or garden) are expected and even embraced as part of the gem’s character. This different standard for clarity means that beautiful emeralds can be found at more accessible price points than flawless diamonds. For those looking at halo engagement rings in Golden, CO, emerald center stones surrounded by diamond accents create stunning visual contrast.

Colombian emeralds are generally considered the finest, but we also offer excellent value options from Zambia and Brazil. The Zambian emeralds, in particular, often provide better clarity and a slightly bluish-green tone that many of our customers at our Boulder jewelry store prefer. For the budget-conscious, we suggest considering lab-created emeralds, which offer exceptional color and clarity at about one-third the price of their natural counterparts.

Morganite: The Rose Gold Companion

Morganite has experienced a tremendous surge in popularity over the past decade, largely due to its soft pink to peach color that pairs beautifully with rose gold settings. This member of the beryl family (related to emerald) offers good durability with a hardness of 7.5-8, making it suitable for engagement rings in Arvada, CO and other fine jewelry.

What makes morganite an exceptional value is its availability in larger carat sizes at affordable prices. While large diamonds increase in price exponentially with size, morganite remains relatively affordable even in impressive carat weights. At Creekside Jewelers in Denver, we frequently create stunning morganite pieces that offer impressive visual impact at a fraction of diamond prices.

The subtle color of morganite means it pairs beautifully with diamond rings in Golden, CO, either as accent stones or in complementary pieces. Its affordable price point also allows for larger, statement-making designs that would be prohibitively expensive with diamonds. For brides seeking rose gold wedding rings for women in Golden, CO, morganite offers the perfect complementary stone.

Aquamarine: Ocean-Inspired Beauty

Aquamarine, with its serene blue to blue-green colors reminiscent of sea water, offers excellent value and versatility. Another member of the beryl family, aquamarine features good hardness (7.5-8) and exceptional clarity, as it typically forms with fewer inclusions than emeralds. At Creekside Jewelers’ gemstone collection in Golden, aquamarine is consistently one of our most popular colored gemstones.

What sets aquamarine apart as a value proposition is its availability in larger sizes at reasonable prices. While diamonds increase exponentially in price with size, aquamarines offer a more linear pricing structure. This allows customers at our Golden jewelry store to acquire impressive center stones for solitaire engagement rings without breaking the bank.

The color range of aquamarine is quite varied, from pale sky blue to deeper blue-green shades. Generally, the more intense blue stones command higher prices, but even the lighter hues offer exceptional beauty and clarity. Aquamarine pairs beautifully with both white metals (white gold, platinum) and diamond rings, creating an elegant, timeless look that many of our customers at Creekside Jewelers in Denver prefer for both everyday wear and special occasions.

Spinel: The Underappreciated Gem

Spinel may be one of the jewelry world’s best-kept secrets. This remarkable gemstone offers exceptional brilliance, durability (8 on Mohs scale), and occurs naturally in a rainbow of colors including red, pink, blue, purple, and black. Historically, many famous “rubies” in royal collections were later identified as red spinels, including the “Black Prince’s Ruby” in the British Imperial State Crown.

What makes spinel particularly valuable is its completely natural beauty—most spinels on the market are not treated or enhanced in any way, unlike many other gemstones. At Creekside Jewelers in Boulder, we’ve seen growing interest in spinel as consumers become more educated about this exceptional gemstone.

The value proposition of spinel is remarkable. Red spinel offers similar appearance to ruby at roughly half the price, while blue spinel provides an alternative to sapphire at a 30-40% discount. For those considering custom jewelry in Golden, CO, spinel’s versatility makes it an excellent choice for unique, personalized pieces. Its durability also makes it suitable for engagement rings in Boulder and other everyday jewelry.

Tanzanite: Rare Blue-Purple Wonder

Tanzanite is a relatively recent discovery in the gemstone world, first found in 1967 near Mount Kilimanjaro in Tanzania—still the only known source in the world. This geographic exclusivity adds to tanzanite’s appeal, as does its mesmerizing blue-purple color that shifts in different lighting conditions (a property called pleochroism). At Creekside Jewelers in Arvada, tanzanite has become increasingly popular for those seeking unique colored gemstones.

With a hardness of 6.5-7, tanzanite requires a bit more care than diamonds or sapphires, making it better suited for occasional wear jewelry or protected settings. Despite this limitation, tanzanite offers exceptional value compared to blue sapphires of similar color quality, typically costing 50-70% less. For customers at our Golden jewelry store seeking statement pieces, tanzanite provides remarkable visual impact at accessible price points.

The finite supply of tanzanite—experts estimate the mines may be depleted within a few decades—adds an investment aspect to these gems. Many customers at Creekside Jewelers in Denver consider tanzanite pieces not only beautiful jewelry but potential heirlooms that may appreciate in value. Tanzanite pairs beautifully with both white metals for a cool, contemporary look, and with diamonds in Golden, CO for added sparkle.

Garnet: More Than Just Red

When most people think of garnets, they envision the common deep red varieties. However, the garnet family offers an impressive range of colors including vibrant greens (tsavorite and demantoid), orange (spessartite), purple-red (rhodolite), and even color-changing varieties. At Creekside Jewelers’ gemstone collection in Golden, we showcase the diversity of this often underappreciated gemstone family.

The value proposition of garnets varies by type. Tsavorite